• 2015 15" MBP Iris + Zotac GTX 970 + Akitio Thunder 2 - OSX El Capitan


    HammerFET

    I've been sitting on this build for a while, meaning to make a build log but its been so long I've forgotten most of it! :eagerness:

    So here's the short and sweet version!

     

    m3uazH7.jpg

     

    My previous build with this card was a water-cooled wall mounted windows gaming machine. This was a great rig for a former student just having started a new job with still a fair bit of time on his hands... Then things got busy, and the water beast became stagnant. Long story short, I converted to mac mostly due to requiring portability yet still wanting a powerful machine that wasn't a total door stop to carry around.

     

     

    So it became that a GTX 970 soon found its way on my book shelf in a nice compact case. Just for kicks, heres my old rig!

     

    zmjNuqT.jpg

     

    Firstly, why did i drop the water-cooling? The original plan was to make a similar wall mounted eGPU. After some pondering I came to the conclusion that this particular card I owned wasn't much of an overclocker. I hadn't actually bothered unlocking the card or overclocking it a whole lot. I had planned to do it, but it had never happened. For 5 months I had used the card running on stock power and it was still maxing out games on my 2560x1080 ultra wide. 

     

    I went ahead a bought the Akitio thunder 2 off a german website, delivered to the UK within two days for a very good price!

     

    I initially used a 120W 12V power brick to run the card, clearly this didn't cut it, and the card would die instantly on load. I resorted to grabbing a Dell DA2 18A power brick and things started working great!

     

    This post by dschjin inspired me to try the noctua fans with the stock heatsink. To my surprise they worked very well and I was getting great temps under load. I could even hold my previous water-cooled overclock and it would hang around 75 degrees C.

     

    I then proceeded to create a funky case cooling design, and two days of drilling later I ended up with this!

     

    5DVPqrz.jpg

     

    It looked great! But it was an awful cooling solution... absolutely useless, wouldn't even hold stock settings before throttling...

     

    I then decided to cut out the entire side and top panel with the idea of finding a grill/mesh material to put in its place. I ended up going with a desktop wire magazine holder like this one:

     

    61cr%2BnJnCgL._SY355_.jpg

     

    Here it is cut out

     

    qbtjIT9.jpg

     

    I then cut it to size and slid it between the fans and the edge of the aluminium case. Its all very much a tight fit and required a lot of effort to close while keeping everything in place.

     

    I used some PCIe power extenders that plugged on the top of the card as two six pin power. They required trimming of the plastic and heat shrink to get the clearance:

     

    J9j28L3.jpg

     

    As you can see the sharp inside of the aluminium enclosure already mangled the nice new heat shrink!

     

    The fans are also just about held in place with some bits of plastic. Due to the design of the heatsink, the fans couldn't be sat flush without having to cut some metal tabs and bending things. the way it is now lets the fans sit tight between the mesh and the heatsink. Once the case is closed, nothing can move.

     

    nRUHuQj.jpg

     

    I then added a power switch with LED (switch contacts go on the dell PSU and led goes to the existing led pins on the Akitio motherboard.

     

    uejRlHW.jpg

     

    hsNJrPV.jpg

     

    chopped up 24pin ate connector is in there as a total bodge job. The wires are breaded in pairs and simply pass through the vent holes of the card. Too easy! The wires are stiff enough that it doesn't really matter anyway.

     

    lyzAyLB.jpg

    qZ5L26S.jpg

    HAhpSC1.jpg

     

    xsv26kP.jpg

    aySqMvd.jpg

     

    Finally, here are a few of my favourite things!

    XY0b6Wn.jpg

    Electrical tape to cover up sharp edges of steel.

    3M VHB tape can stick anything to anything like foam tape! Then come off like it was never there. I swear by this stuff!

    sharpie to coverup dings and dents

    Wago wire to wire clamps, these things are quicker and much more reliable than terminal blocks if you're too lazy to solder wires together. Like me!

    stick on foam to space out bits of floating mesh grill and make a snug fit

    mains powered dremel with EZ click metal cutting disk. This thing makes short work of thick aluminium.

     

    And don't forget boys and girls, always wear protection!

    vAjyK7r.jpg

     

     

    Software woes

     

    Lets just say the hardware was the easy bit.. I started out with a bootcamp of Windows 10 and the card would just about start. It seemed very unreliable, sometimes it would work everytime, then I'd get home one day and the thing just didn't want to start..

     

    Optimus made everything worse, though it was great when it worked.

     

    I ended up going to several installs of windows 10 and 8.1, even a UEFI rebuild..

     

    Finally I gave in a resorted to OSX drivers. Automate GPU is fantastic and it just works. I've been very surprised how well most of my steam library works on OSX. I had a nice surprise the other day when I found out Thief was available for OSX and that sold it to me. I got rid of my windows partition and all my gaming is done in OSX now.

     

    Overall this seems to be a great solution for portable computing and still having the ability to run desktop graphics. I've been very surprised and look forward to Thunderbolt 3 where this should be natively supported!

     

    For those interested, I did manage to get a fair bit of overclocking done within windows when I had it working, here are the results:

     

    CPU temps:

    Zj4y2KS.png

     

    Card info:

    hlb3ZlN.png

     

    Over thunderbolt:

    3Viese5.png

     

    running this card on a Z77 desktop motherboard with i5 3570k @ 4.2GHz gave :

    90OdYXf.png

     

    In OSX again:

    YevlY1v.png


    3 people like this


    User Feedback


    Hey HammerFET, nice work.
    You mentioned you got the Akitio Thunder2 PCIe box for a good price from Germany, well I am looking to purchase a box (I am in the UK). Could you tell me where you bought yours from and how much it was? (inc postage).

     

    Thanks!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites


    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.


    Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By milkyjoe2
      I have one, with dedicated graphics card (AMD R9 M370X) want to know whether it would work because of the possible incompatibility of the thunderbolt controller (TI86/87) of the Node
    • By Seachrome
      Hi!
       
      I've done a lot of research on this forum and on Youtube about getting an eGPU. However, one thing I have noticed from that is that my particular Macbook Pro Retina (13'' early 2015) has a lot of issues with booting up. So, I have a couple of questions before I order my parts. 
       
      1. Is it even worth trying on my Macbook? If it takes me half an hour to finally get it to boot up (it seemed very complicated from the builds I saw), I don't think it's worth the effort. 
      2. Would the GTX 1060 Mini work with the Akitio 2 and the Macbook? 
      3. Does a Razer Core (TB3 to TB2 adapter) share the same issues as the Akitio? If it has an 100% success rate with Bootcamp, I might just shell out for it. 
      4. Finally, is it possible to run an eGPU and Bootcamp on an external SSD? I would love to be able to use my entire internal SSD with OSX at school/work but come home to a huge drive on Windows for all my games and intensive apps. 
       
      Thanks! 
    • By WaY977
      First and foremost: this is a HASSLE-FREE BUILD.
      You will not find creative schematics, acrobatic soldering, custom BIOSes or anything like that: this is pure "just works eGPU" with Win10 bootcamp and an external display (so, no OSX support and no internal monitor either)
       
      Let's begin!

      Hardware:
       
       - Macbook Pro Retina Mid 2014 with nVidia GT750M
       - Akitio Thunder2
       - MSI GTX 1070 Armor 8G OC
       - Dell DA-2 12V  (ended up not using it)
      - Old Corsair 540W Modular PSU
       
      Setup:
       
      None. Absolutely no software setup. I had my previously working Win10 bootcamp machine installed, and it was a regular, apple-certified, Win10 installation done via bootcamp assistant, so no UEFI workaround or custom BIOS.
       
      The works
       

       
      Got my Akitio, unbox and open. Just 2 screws and voila.
       

       
      Removed the back plate (4 little screws)
       

       
      I unplugged both the fan and the led cable and removed the glued support for the cable, you can still see the glue
      Removing the fan was just a matter of removing 4 screws, the LED light took just a bit of force and it popped out of the socket.
      Here's all the things from the Akitio you will not use.
       

       
      As you can see from the hardware list, I decided to go with a full sized GTX card, and not just a full-sized one, a pretty big one at that.
      The MSI GTX1070 Armor OC does not have any LEDs or fancy things, just 2 big (and quiet) fans and that's that.
       

       
      So, of course, I had to bend the Akitio to make room for the card.
      I went with the "jeweller's screwdriver" technique. Fast and easy: just put a little flat screwdriver near the soldering at the bottom of the enclosure and work your way in lightly with a hammer.
      Took me 1 minute and the little solderings popped open.
       

       
      Now it was just a matter of applying a bit of brute force and bend the enclosure open.
      Not pretty, I know... but I'm not looking for pretty. Besides, the card is so long it covers the bent enclosure and then some!
       


       
      I gotta say, I was getting pretty impatient at this point.
      I put the card in, adjusted the two screws to set it in place and checked the spacing between the card and the bent enclosure. 
      Everything was in order. Not pretty, again, but in order.
       


       
      At this point, I encountered a little snafu in my plan.
      I had bought the famous Dell DA-2 to power my GPU.. turns out this monster of a card has an 8 pin power slot, not a 6 pin one.
      Huh. Now what? 
      Remember, this was supposed to be a hassle-free installation, no soldering or complicated workarounds.
       
      I remembered I had an oldish PSU from my desktop era sitting in a closed, took it out, plugged it in and got a nice 8-pin cable to power my GPU.
      (of course I had to use the paperclip-trick to power the PSU, but it's so basic, I'm not counting that as a hassle).
       


       
      To power the Akitio, since this a... let's say it again, everyone... hassle free build, I didn't want to use any custom made barrels or anything, so I used the original PSU, plugged it in and that's it.
      It was time to power it all up and see what the future brings.
      Thunderbolt cable connected, external monitor plugged in with a displayport cable, everything powered up... turn on MBP: nothing. Black screen.
       
      Huh.
      Powered down, tried to plug the thunderbold cable in AFTER the boot.
      Got a "hey I found something" sound from Windows, but nothing else.
      Reboot.
      Now the MBP started in Bootcamp, and Device Manager said there was a "Microsoft Basic Display Adapter".
      Bingo!
      Downloaded latest nVidia drivers, gave it a go: oh, damn! I have 2 video cards!
       
      Rebooted again
      The external monitor came to life, so I closed the lid on my MacBook (I'm using it in clamshell mode, I have no need for another screen) and there it was.
      With this solution, you don't even need to go and disable the "internal" 750M,
       
      Didn't have the time to make a 3D Mark benchmark, yet... but these were the settings of my WoW client yesterday
       

       
      and @2560x1440 with all ultra settings I had 67fps. Not too shabby
       
      Future implementations:
       
      - power the Akitio via the barrel to remove an external PSU
      - organize cables and spaces
      - switch PSU: this one has a terrible case of "coil whining", it looks like I'm skinning a cat...
      - IF I ever have any spare time, try and put everything inside a box: I'm thinking of one of those ikea metal boxes... 
       
      Thank you all for your help and... comments appreciated! (everything but: "it's ugly!". That one I know )
    • By J95
      Game Ready
        •Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Remastered, The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Special Edition, Obduction, Titanfall 2
        •Battlefield 1, Civilization VI, Steep: Open Beta, Tom Clancy’s The Division Survival DLC, Watch Dogs 2

      Game Ready VR
        •Eagle Flight, Obduction, Serious Sam VR: The Last Hope, and the Oculus Touch launch titles

      New Features
        •Enhanced the performance and quality of the motion vectors provided by the Motion-Estimation-Only mode of the video encoder, specifically in stereo VR use cases.

      This version adds several security improvements.

      Added or updated the following SLI profiles:
        •Titanfall 2 - disabled SLI

      3D Vision Profiles
        •No 3D Vision profiles were added with this version.

      3D Compatibility Mode Profiles
        •No compatibility mode profiles were added with this version.
       
      Windows 10 Fixed Issues:
      Install the Display Container via co-installer. [200228206]
        •[375.86, GP104] Corruption in YouTube video playback when two or more videos are playing at the same time in Chrome. [1843100]
        •Clean up the escape calls that use physical addresses. [1626231]

      Windows 8.1/Windows 8/Windows 7 Fixed Issues:
        •Install the Display Container via co-installer. [200228206]
        •NV_ESC_ID_NVAPI_REPORT_WFD_HOTPLUG and NV_ESC_ID_NVAPI_ENUM_DISPLAYIDS_EX don't validate the size of input, causing a KERNEL_SECURITY_CHECK_FAILURE. [1808374]
        •Clean up the escape calls that use physical addresses. [1626231]
        •NVL_ESC_ID_COMMON_REGISTRY_ACCESS escalates user privileges when the registry is accessed. [1359976]


      Software Module Versions
        •NView - 148.03
        •HD Audio Driver - 1.3.34.17
        •NVIDIA PhysX System Software - 9.16.0318
        •GeForce Experience - 3.2 (3.2.0.91)
        •CUDA - 8.0
       
       
       
      Windows 10
       64-bit
        32-bit 
             Windows 7 & 8.1
       64-bit
       32-bit
       
       
       
    • By Shez
      No issue up to now, everything is stable, easy and cheap setup. However, Nvidia Optimus isn't working with latest Nvidia drivers.
       
      Hardware:
       - Mac mini Late 2012 (MD387LL/A) / Macbook Pro Retina Late 2013 (ME293LL/A)
       - Akitio Thunder2
       - Zotac GTX1050Ti
       - Samsung T3 Portable SSD - 250GB (for Windows To Go)
       - DC 12V/12.5A from Aliexpress
       
      Setup:
       - Install Windows 10 as Windows To Go with Rufus;
       - Install Bootcamp;
       - Reboot to Windows with Akitio connected and install latest Nvidia Driver;
       
      System Start:
       - Connect External SSD with Windows To Go to your Mac;
       - Power up and hold down ALT keyboard;
       - Connect Akitio and wait 2-4 minutes;
       - Choose Windows from boot menu;
       
      sorry guys, I can't attach files here, every times it gives me an error. I uploaded images and benchmarks to my google drive here