timohour Posted October 16, 2015 Author Share Posted October 16, 2015 Thanks for the info @timohour but I already tried all of them. This is probably a driver\hardware problem, not TOLUD because the 660gtx is correctly recognized, but with an external screen the system is very unstable (on Win 10 at least, I'm now trying on Win 8.1). @Tech Inferno Fan It is normal that setup_var "xxx" shows "GUID does not match expected GUID, taking it nevertheless, expected a different size of the Setup variable, continue con care, bla bla bla"?. The output fon vars seems to me the right one, anyway. its ok UPDATE: No luck on win 8.1 too (( all three gpu (i, e, d) are allocated but on external screen the system is very unstable. :\UPDATE 2: Ok, I managed to isolate the problem: the truth is that everything works (optimus, Gen2, hotplug, plug from boot, disabling NV5200 or not etc...) a perfect system but ONLY with the internal screen. Every time I tried to connect my 24''... the 660 driver crashed, so the problem is the connection with an external screen (I tried both HDMI and DP). @timohour do you use one of these? [ATTACH=CONFIG]16265[/ATTACH] I connected my screen on the R9-280x with DVI but I can't see how this is any different than your HDMI signal. You said that the same setup (adapter+card+screen) works flawlessly @ x 1.2 with your 2570p... That's weird cause it really seems like an adapter fault... Could you pls try to set your EC port @ Gen1 speed using UEFI vars? If your gear works fine with your 2570p it could mean that the EC port is faulty and it won't hold gen 2 signal... http://forum.techinferno.com/dell-latitude-vostro-precision/9690-14-dell-latitude-e6430-performance-upgrades-system-mods-19.html#post144322 you can find instructions here @sangemaru Is there any possibility to test your adapter with an other system to check if it can hold Gen 2 signals... Mine was working but AMD drivers was proved to be more versatile than NVidia in such cases Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 16, 2015 Share Posted October 16, 2015 its okI connected my screen on the R9-280x with DVI but I can't see how this is any different than your HDMI signal. You said that the same setup (adapter+card+screen) works flawlessly @ x 1.2 with your 2570p... That's weird cause it really seems like an adapter fault... Could you pls try to set your EC port @ Gen1 speed using UEFI vars? If your gear works fine with your 2570p it could mean that the EC port is faulty and it won't hold gen 2 signal...http://forum.techinferno.com/dell-latitude-vostro-precision/9690-14-dell-latitude-e6430-performance-upgrades-system-mods-19.html#post144322 you can find instructions here @sangemaru Is there any possibility to test your adapter with an other system to check if it can hold Gen 2 signals...Mine was working but AMD drivers was proved to be more versatile than NVidia in such casesI can try Gen1, but in your post you said: UPDATE: This will work only for devices that are connected on the machine prior to boot. If you disconnect or hotplug the machine it will revert to Gen2 speeds as pointed here. thanks @Tech Inferno Fan for pointing that out.How this works? Booting with EC already in give me a freeze\blackscreen. Anyway with the internal screen the Gen2 works fine, so I don't think yours is the right answer. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 16, 2015 Author Share Posted October 16, 2015 I can try Gen1, but in your post you said: UPDATE: This will work only for devices that are connected on the machine prior to boot. If you disconnect or hotplug the machine it will revert to Gen2 speeds as pointed here. thanks @Tech Inferno Fan for pointing that out.How this works? Booting with EC already in give me a freeze\blackscreen. Anyway with the internal screen the Gen2 works fine, so I don't think yours is the right answer.Follow this post to keep your iGPU enabled to avoid blackscreen. Check the next post for the variables Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 Ok I too can confirm it: The system is stable with Gen1 (but still with a LITTLE lag while opening windows). Anyway must be a driver+hardware problem, in my opinion, 'cause on internal-screen-only the Gen2 link works ( @sangemaru could you try?) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 17, 2015 Author Share Posted October 17, 2015 Ok I too can confirm it: The system is stable with Gen1 (but still with a LITTLE lag while opening windows). Anyway must be a driver+hardware problem, in my opinion, 'cause on internal-screen-only the Gen2 link works ( @sangemaru could you try?)I am sure that my r9-280x hold a stable x1.2 link with my EC homemade adapter, even when running a couple of benchmarks. No Nvidia card was tested though. Also other laptops from the same generation (E6230, E6530) have managed successfully to establish a Gen 2 speed link.And the same problem shows on both you dGPU model and the iGPU model... I don't think that there is a manufacturer fault on your mb and the EC can not hold Gen2 speeds...Are you running the latest Intel driver?The problem is still in W10 or W8.1? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 I am sure that my r9-280x hold a stable x1.2 link with my EC homemade adapter, even when running a couple of benchmarks. No Nvidia card was tested though. Also other laptops from the same generation (E6230, E6530) have managed successfully to establish a Gen 2 speed link.And the same problem shows on both you dGPU model and the iGPU model... I don't think that there is a manufacturer fault on your mb and the EC can not hold Gen2 speeds...Are you running the latest Intel driver?The problem is still in W10 or W8.1?Yes on both. On Win 8.1 the Gen2 link is a little more stable (I can open some windows before continuous driver reboots), but Gen1 has a little micro-lag while opening new windows (very little but noteworthy). On Win 10 the Gen2 link is much more unstable (black screen with only the mouse visible, then crash), but the Gen1 is better (no micro-lag).The intel driver is the last one (but I can disable the Optimus\HD4000 and the problem is the same, so probably is on Nvidia, if any). @sangemaru the model of your external monitor? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 17, 2015 Author Share Posted October 17, 2015 Yes on both. On Win 8.1 the Gen2 link is a little more stable (I can open some windows before continuous driver reboots), but Gen1 has a little micro-lag while opening new windows (very little but noteworthy). On Win 10 the Gen2 link is much more unstable (black screen with only the mouse visible, then crash), but the Gen1 is better (no micro-lag).The intel driver is the last one (but I can disable the Optimus\HD4000 and the problem is the same, so probably is on Nvidia, if any).I really can't find any reason why this is happening other than a hardware defect either from the laptop or the eGPU hardware. And since the whole setup works great on your 2570p I can only assume it is your laptop. Is there any other GPU you could borrow and try (even older)? I use to do my first test with an old 8400 with a faulty DVI I salvaged from work. Also use your Service Tag to check on your warranty. These machines came with a Pro 3 year warranty and it is very possible that it is still under it...If you are quite sure it is a mb defect you should contact them in order to replace it.Offcourse you should find another way to prove that the EC slot is faulty (maybe test with a cheap EC-USB 3.0 chip) cause I don't think they will fall for "Hey, my eGPU is not working @ Gen2 speeds..." Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 I really can't find any reason why this is happening other than a hardware defect either from the laptop or the eGPU hardware. And since the whole setup works great on your 2570p I can only assume it is your laptop. Is there any other GPU you could borrow and try (even older)? I use to do my first test with an old 8400 with a faulty DVI I salvaged from work. Also use your Service Tag to check on your warranty. These machines came with a Pro 3 year warranty and it is very possible that it is still under it...If you are quite sure it is a mb defect you should contact them in order to replace it.Offcourse you should find another way to prove that the EC slot is faulty (maybe test with a cheap EC-USB 3.0 chip) cause I don't think they will fall for "Hey, my eGPU is not working @ Gen2 speeds..."I don't understand: Ok, lets assume a faulty motherboard, but the problem is that Gen2 works without problems if no external screen is connected (in optimus mode). Is that for the lower resolution? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tech Inferno Fan Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 I don't understand: Ok, lets assume a faulty motherboard, but the problem is that Gen2 works without problems if no external screen is connected (in optimus mode). Is that for the lower resolution?Unlike the 2570P that has a EC slot soldered onto the systemboard, Dell systems often use a daughterboard that connects onto the systemboard to provide an EC slot. If there is even a small impedance mismatch then at 5GHz transmission speed of Gen2 it will add signal reflections leading to data loss. Switching to the slower Gen1 solving the problem.As a start you want the best possible eGPU adapter (PE4L 2.1b or PE4C V3.0) with soldered cable to test with. If still not getting Gen2 then consider testing another video card, another culprit that can add signal noise.As timohour suggests, Dell aren't going to replace the EC components due to Gen2 instability. It's been noted that Dell have been downgrading their updated newer BIOS on Gen2-capable EC slot machines at Gen1 speed. That tells me Dell has an inexpensive solution to the problem. As Dell aren't advertising a Gen2 EC slot it's a solution that's within their marketting spec. Unfortunately. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 Unlike the 2570P that has a EC slot soldered onto the systemboard, Dell systems often use a daughterboard that connects onto the systemboard to provide an EC slot. If there is even a small impedance mismatch then at 5GHz transmission speed of Gen2 it will add signal reflections leading to data loss. Switching to the slower Gen1 solving the problem.As a start you want the best possible eGPU adapter (PE4L 2.1b or PE4C V3.0) with soldered cable to test with. If still not getting Gen2 then consider testing another video card, another culprit that can add signal noise.As timohour suggests, Dell aren't going to replace the EC components due to Gen2 instability. It's been noted that Dell have been downgrading their updated newer BIOS on Gen2-capable EC slot machines at Gen1 speed. That tells me Dell has an inexpensive solution to the problem. As Dell aren't advertising a Gen2 EC slot it's a solution that's within their marketting spec. Unfortunately.Thanks @Tech Inferno Fan, but I still don't understand why on internal screen Gen2 works (lower resolution maybe?). So... lets do some razor-exclusion between me and @sangemaru:SO: Different: Win 8.1 (Win 10 too) and Win 10 BIOS: Different, A16 and A7dGPU: Different: NV5200 and noneeGPU: Different, Gtx660 and R9-270x (different type too)eGPU port: I tried DP and HDMIeGPU adapter: Different, PE4L 2.1b and EXP GDCCPU: Same i7-3740QM (but unlikely)MONITOR: Dell U2412m and ????GEN2 ON INTERNAL SCREEN: Works and ????Sigh.... so probably it's true, is a faulty EC port. Can I change it? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tech Inferno Fan Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 Thanks @Tech Inferno Fan, but I still don't understand why on internal screen Gen2 works (lower resolution maybe?). So... lets do some razor-exclusion between me and @sangemaru:SO: Different: Win 8.1 (Win 10 too) and Win 10 BIOS: Different, A16 and A7dGPU: Different: NV5200 and noneeGPU: Different, Gtx660 and R9-270x (different type too)eGPU port: I tried DP and HDMIeGPU adapter: Different, PE4L 2.1b and EXP GDCCPU: Same i7-3740QM (but unlikely)MONITOR: Dell U2412m and ????GEN2 ON INTERNAL SCREEN: Works and ????Sigh.... so probably it's true, is a faulty EC port. Can I change it?AMD drivers have much better fault tolerance to unreliable Gen2 links than NVidia. Your comparing two very different eGPU configurations.There's an easy way to identify the Gen2 link eGPU issue. Play some music on your notebook's soundcard+speaker while doing graphics on your eGPU. When the egpu link retransmissions occur the music will start cutting out. After a bit you may see the system either freeze or BSOD. Set Gen1 and repeat the test. There you won't find any such hiccups. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sangemaru Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 Yes on both. On Win 8.1 the Gen2 link is a little more stable (I can open some windows before continuous driver reboots), but Gen1 has a little micro-lag while opening new windows (very little but noteworthy). On Win 10 the Gen2 link is much more unstable (black screen with only the mouse visible, then crash), but the Gen1 is better (no micro-lag). The intel driver is the last one (but I can disable the Optimus\HD4000 and the problem is the same, so probably is on Nvidia, if any). @sangemaru the model of your external monitor? My external monitor is an old Fujits B24W ECO. Unfortunately at present I have no other workable machine with EC on-hand (I do have an e4300 but it needs repairs before i can make it work - maybe I could report on it sometime next week). I could test with an HD4870 or HD3870 eGPU, but once more, next week at the earliest. It would be really sucky if the adapter could actually deliver Gen2 but the problem were with the machines . 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 My external monitor is an old Fujits B24W ECO.Unfortunately at present I have no other workable machine with EC on-hand (I do have an e4300 but it needs repairs before i can make it work - maybe I could report on it sometime next week). I could test with an HD4870 or HD3870 eGPU, but once more, next week at the earliest. It would be really sucky if the adapter could actually deliver Gen2 but the problem were with the machines . Nice! Could you test if Gen2 eGPU with "Laptop Screen only" (no external LCD connected) give you any problem? UPDATE: Ah ok. Neither the e6430 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sangemaru Posted October 17, 2015 Share Posted October 17, 2015 No, I had no troubles with Gen2 enabled so long as I wasn't putting any load on the eGPU. My problems appeared the moment I tried to connect anything to it. If I booted the machine with the adapter connected but with no monitor, Windows would be perfectly stable and report Gen2 speeds. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 17, 2015 Author Share Posted October 17, 2015 Unlike the 2570P that has a EC slot soldered onto the systemboard, Dell systems often use a daughterboard that connects onto the systemboard to provide an EC slot. If there is even a small impedance mismatch then at 5GHz transmission speed of Gen2 it will add signal reflections leading to data loss. Switching to the slower Gen1 solving the problem.As a start you want the best possible eGPU adapter (PE4L 2.1b or PE4C V3.0) with soldered cable to test with. If still not getting Gen2 then consider testing another video card, another culprit that can add signal noise. Thanks, that was my first thought but I realised that the EC on the E6430 is on the motherboard... Top left And my e6430, your e6230 and khenglish's e6530( motherboard), worked flawlessly... I am thinking to grub some gear just for testing... Although I may have to say goodbye to this beauty since they got me a new computer at work... 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 18, 2015 Share Posted October 18, 2015 Some faulty discoveries: I completly disabled the NV5200 (I really don't need it, is only more heat to the CPU and the cooling heat pipes) but since then the docking station has dropped the DP and HDMI support. Yeah, I know, as from the schematics they are wired to the dGpu directly, but for fun I tried: Setting: Primary Display, Variable: 0x1D4 Option: Auto, Value: 0x3 Option: IGFX, Value: 0x0 Option: PEG, Value: 0x1 Option: PCI Bus, Value: 0x2 Setting: Internal Graphics, Variable: 0x1D8 Option: Auto, Value: 0x2 Option: Disabled, Value: 0x0 Option: Enabled, Value: 0x1 Setting: Port 3 PCIe Speed (Gen1/2) [Expresscard Slot] Variable: 0xB4 Option: 0x0 (Auto), Option: 0x1 (Gen1), Option: 0x2 (Gen 2) Setting: iGPU Port Configuration, Variable: 0x1D7 Option: Disabled, Value: 0x0 Option: Enabled, Value: 0x1 Setting: iGPU Digital Port B Mode, Variable: 0x1DA Option: Port is fully muxed with dGPU, Value: 0x0 Option: Port is not muxed with dGPU, Value: 0x1 Option: Port supports HPD only, Value: 0x2 Setting: iGPU Digital Port C Mode, Variable: 0x1DB Option: Port is fully muxed with dGPU, Value: 0x0 Option: Port is not muxed with dGPU, Value: 0x1 Option: Port supports dHPD only, Value: 0x2 Setting: iGPU Digital Port D Mode, Variable: 0x1DC Option: Port is fully muxed with dGPU, Value: 0x0 Option: Port is not muxed with dGPU, Value: 0x1 Option: Port supports HPD only, Value: 0x2 without any success (luckly the VGA is on the iGpu, at least). By the way, the system is pretty much stable as now (not taking into account the Gen2 problem ). Next step: CPU overclock. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 18, 2015 Author Share Posted October 18, 2015 I completly disabled the NV5200 (I really don't need it, is only more heat to the CPU and the cooling heat pipes) but since then the docking station has dropped the DP and HDMI support.Interesting! Do you have any proof that disabling the NVS5200M helps with your temperatures? I remember when I applied the battery tweaks that when I disabled the dGPU completely I had bigger idle consumption than when enabled but not using it.... I thought that the same goes for heat emissions and that's why I have it enabled... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 18, 2015 Share Posted October 18, 2015 Interesting! Do you have any proof that disabling the NVS5200M helps with your temperatures? I remember when I applied the battery tweaks that when I disabled the dGPU completely I had bigger idle consumption than when enabled but not using it.... I thought that the same goes for heat emissions and that's why I have it enabled...I don't know for the watt consumption, but temps are -2° usually (oh well, but it can be accidental). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 18, 2015 Share Posted October 18, 2015 1680x945?14 0" 1680x945 LED Screen for Dell Latitude E6430 LCD Laptop | eBay Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 18, 2015 Author Share Posted October 18, 2015 1680x945?14 0" 1680x945 LED Screen for Dell Latitude E6430 LCD Laptop | eBay1680x945 LCD does not fit correctly as attempted here.I don't think it would have any problem working if your screen is already 900p. The proble is as you can see above quoted from http://forum.techinferno.com/dell-latitude-vostro-precision/6980-14-dell-latitude-e6440-owners-lounge.html, it seems like the screen may not physically fit. Contact the seller for more info on the E6430. I have never tried it. If he accepts returns you can try it and if it doesn't fit send it back.Since my E6430 came originally with 900p I would be more interested on a real upgrade such as a 14" LVDS 1080p screen or an 14" IPS LVDS screen.If you find out that it fits but yours came originally with a 768p screen you will also have to buy the 2ch LVDs cable in order for the new screen to work correctly (same applies for an 768p-->900p upgrade).Part no for HD+ cable is JTC08 or CYM5CJTC08 is stated as HD+ cable CYM5C is stated as FHD/HD+ cable although there is no version of E6430 that would come with FHD screen. You can find one of these as low as 15$ but I can't find any info on what is the difference btw the two. If you are interested I could try to find what is my part number (my laptop came with an 900p screen and it is most probably going to be a JTC08).. Seems to me that the CYM5C is the cable for the E6530 version of the cable but it will work for the E6430 too. also it is the same cable for both iGPU and dGPU models.Successful upgrade from 768p -- > 1080p on a similar hardware E6530 laptop using CYM5C cable 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 19, 2015 Share Posted October 19, 2015 (edited) Cooling mod done! Edited January 12, 2016 by Dewos 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 19, 2015 Author Share Posted October 19, 2015 Cooling mod done! ... Results: Idle [39<> 46]° (before: 45° <> 55°) Ts Bench [Max 79°] (before: 90° with throttle to x34!) ... How it works with the UEFI vars? Nice!!! Follow the NEWBIE GUIDE TO TWEAKING THE DELL E6430 by badbadbad. If you have problems ask here. Would be helpful for your OCed temps to operate with bottom lid open and use laptop cooling pad (or a fan pointing on the heatsink). enjoy the power... if possible supply prime95 temps and add the 4C @ 3.8GHz temperature results... It would be helpful to evaluate how efficient your CPU is as done here as described http://forum.techinferno.com/throttlestop-realtemp-discussion/6958-haswell-step-backwards-ivy-bridge-i-have-some-shocking-tdp-results.html#post95181 it would be interesting to see where your 3740QM ranks. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 19, 2015 Share Posted October 19, 2015 Nice!!!it would be interesting to see where your 3740QM ranks. Good with 1c (x40.x variable, almost x41). but pretty bad with 4c, (very variable, sometimes keeps x36, sometimes x.35.x or x34.x ) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
timohour Posted October 19, 2015 Author Share Posted October 19, 2015 Good with 1c (x40.x variable, almost x41). but pretty bad with 4c, (very variable, sometimes keeps x36, sometimes x.35.x or x34.x )[ATTACH=CONFIG]16302[/ATTACH][ATTACH=CONFIG]16303[/ATTACH] You are probably TDP throttled... Set your Long and Short Duration Limit @ 80W and 100W respectively (List of UEFI vars) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dewos Posted October 19, 2015 Share Posted October 19, 2015 You are probably TDP throttled... Set your Long and Short Duration Limit @ 80W and 100W respectively (List of UEFI vars) What value I should set? But first.... Is it safe? I really don't want to fry my CPU UPDATE: moreover my PSU is 90W Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.