Ashtefere

Alienware M18x GPU Cooling Design

37 posts in this topic

Documentation

Take a look at those heatpipes! *phew!*

3 thick heapipes per GPU. This thing can easily take a couple of 485m's.

The questions remain:

  • Power Circuitry? is it going to be enough? (probably)
  • Bios whitelisting? Will the bios block non-approved cards? (also, probably)

I am moving in August, and my job contract ends in July, so I will be buying my m18x in sept-oct this year. If by then they still dont have the 485m sli as a selection, my plan is to:

  1. Buy the base config with 460m sli from USA
  2. Buy the 485m sli pair from logicalblueone (local supplier) and MAKE IT WORK
  3. ???
  4. Profit!

Im sure someone will want to buy an SLI pair of 460m's somewhere on ebay if I can get it to work, but overall, I'm excited and hopeful!

I was in doubt about the 485m's until I saw the cooling. It looks monstrous!

As soon as I know everything is all working, I am going to proceed to see if I can do any cooling improvements to this behemoth. It will be interesting to see if they learned from all our work on the M17x-R2.

-Ash

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I told ya, the cooling is much improved this generation. The R3 has a similar 3 heatpipe design except it seems with the added ducting and plate over the fans, the M18x will have better airflow. One thing I wish they hadn't done is put the GPU's in the middle again like they did with the R2, that is extremely annoying when you need to repaste. Since it can handle a 330W PSU, I'd surmise that the power circuitry is more than adequate for 485M SLi.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The CPU heatsink is placed close to the exhaust and back edge of computer unlike the M17xR2 having this in the center of the system. That's an improvement. The extra copper pipes are going to be excellent at keeping the systems cooler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Two threads, same topic and title?

One is CPU and the other is GPU :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To be honest I didn't notice it until you mentioned it...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

GPU cooling on this model seems great, I think the problem is the CPU cooling.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After pasting my memory chips I noticed they weren't quite touching the heatsink (dell 6970 in m17x, but essentially same as 18x for area over memory).

That said, temps dropped massively vs. pads....even without proper contact.

I was wondering how bad of an idea it'd be if I picked up a thin sheet of copper and affixed it to the heatsink over the memory chips.

1. to close the gap

2. I'd use silver, but it's super expensive. Copper's a decent conductor.

Would really like some input before I do something potentially (more) retarded (than usual).

Edited by kune

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The problem is that you can't properly attach the copper shin to the heatsink, there is always some air between the copper and the heatsink, which is really insulating.

Why did you remove the thermal pads? And which temps dropped? Usually the gap between the memory and the heatsink is about 0.5-1.0mm, and this too big for a proper use of thermal paste. Pads are the best way to go imo, you only have to be careful that the pads are compressible and not too thick, because this will increase the gap between the die and the heatsink.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Because I had an extra GPU to mess around with.

Memory temps are what dropped, and they dropped by a good 20C ++ vs. the terribad Dell stock pad job. I saw memory temps around 100C before.

10minxtremeburn.th.png

Thanks for adding some logic to my bad heatsink idea lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looking at pictures I would also say that the new types of fans they are using in the R3 and M18x R1 are great too. For quieter and better air flow.

I know I would sure like to have those fans in my R2 let alone the new cooling design. :Banane52:

Cheers. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Check this out guys... (these are words copied directly from M18x manual - so I don't own these words they are property of Dell+Alienware)

AC Adapter

Output current

240 W

12.30 A (continuous)

330 W

16.92 A

Output power

240 W

240 W

330 W

330 W

Rated output voltage

19.50 VDC

Temperature range

Operating

240 W

0 °C to 40 °C (32 °F to 104 °F)

330 W

10 °C to 35 °C (50 °F to 95 °F)

Storage

–40 °C to 70 °C (–40 °F to 158 °F)

Connector types

DC connector

3-pin, 7.4 mm plug

AC connector

3-pin — C13 (150 W)

3-pin — C13 (240 W)

Now if anyone remembers my overclocked system that I used a custom air cooled design on my power-supply? I had temps atleast up to 120 degrees Fahrenheit. So that means the temps were well above the safe rating. If we overclock on that 330W I think it is important for the life of the power-supply to do the same and add a cooler to it if overclocking to maintain lower than the rated 95 degrees Fahrenheit. This may not be news but to me that is.

http://forum.techinferno.com/general-notebook-discussions/215-laptop-ac-dc-power-adapter-cooler.html

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So did anyone end up making custom silver or copper shims to displace the extre heat? Did you go back to using the pads? Curious to hear what worked best.

Good Luck! StevenX

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The problem is that you can't properly attach the copper shin to the heatsink, there is always some air between the copper and the heatsink, which is really insulating.

Why did you remove the thermal pads? And which temps dropped? Usually the gap between the memory and the heatsink is about 0.5-1.0mm, and this too big for a proper use of thermal paste. Pads are the best way to go imo, you only have to be careful that the pads are compressible and not too thick, because this will increase the gap between the die and the heatsink.

I did the same, - pasted the memory chips with TX-4. Had to apply a very thick layer on the chips but it was well worth it - 10-20C drop across the board. Pads are no longer a good solution for GDDR5 the way I see it.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, if the gap between the die and the heatsink can get minimized by removing the thermal pads, the temps can really improve.

Recently I got to the conclusion, that the vram modules aren't running that hot... the modules on the back of the 470m which I put in the M15x weren't cooled at all by a heatsink or similar, and it worked fine.

I realized that in the G73JW the gap between heatsink and vram modules was pretty huge and Asus filled it with a chewing-gum like paste, and the system worked fine too. I guess the vram modules don't need as much cooling as generally assumed... I should try measuring the temps of the modules under load sometime.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is virtually impossible for a VRAM module to overheat, even when bare naked. A VRM module though, can but this is very rare. Two very different circumstances separated by just 1 letter.

Toms hardware guide get this mixed up way too fucking much. So do a lot of online hardware stores.

-Ash

Edited by Ashtefere
2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did it with my R2 here i know is on different forum but i hope OPs dont cut out the knowledge.

M17x-R2 CFX 5870 modding for extreme oc

After pasting my memory chips I noticed they weren't quite touching the heatsink (dell 6970 in m17x, but essentially same as 18x for area over memory).

That said, temps dropped massively vs. pads....even without proper contact.

I was wondering how bad of an idea it'd be if I picked up a thin sheet of copper and affixed it to the heatsink over the memory chips.

1. to close the gap

2. I'd use silver, but it's super expensive. Copper's a decent conductor.

Would really like some input before I do something potentially (more) retarded (than usual).

Edited by svl7
link was broken, fixed it for you ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So not a bad idea at all using aluminum and paste on both sides and not a bad idea on using just paste so how bout just using a thick paste on the vram and one that has long reliability that doesn't bake out like the IC Diamond in the test/giveaway... Its a paste that doesn't exactly melt like some others so you may be able to add extra for a thicker application over the vram chips so it contacts the chips and the normal heatsink so no extra material from a shim would be needed and would prevent a small amount of heat trapped by using the shim since the shim isn't "soldered".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Aye! U R right . Cooling the vram is not pressing isue it mostly stand for 1300Mhz EZ without cooling. I have not checked but i sore they had some reference standard up to that XXX it must work stable. The pressing issue is the GPU cooling m17x GPU cooling is relatively not bad but is lack of proper design. Since the highest gpu is 5870 for m17x dell had no interest to do anything. R3 housing a single 6970M performs similar than 2 5870 not really point to go for single.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Aye! U R right . Cooling the vram is not pressing isue it mostly stand for 1300Mhz EZ without cooling. I have not checked but i sore they had some reference standard up to that XXX it must work stable. The pressing issue is the GPU cooling m17x GPU cooling is relatively not bad but is lack of proper design. Since the highest gpu is 5870 for m17x dell had no interest to do anything. R3 housing a single 6970M performs similar than 2 5870 not really point to go for single.

there is a point to get a single 6970m the R3 M17x having one gpu you don't have to deal with crossfire problems (there aren't really any but microstutter and that's not a big deal), its lighter than the R2 and supports the 2nd generation I7 chipset, faster and more amounts of ram and sata 3 hard drive support. So getting an R3 is a nice powerful portable package that doesn't have crossfire issues. R2 has the RGB display and fully unlocked tdp on CPU with xm first generation I7 chips.

Edited by mw86
changed data 3 to sata 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know the tech works behind R3, i mean for me is no point only i find one attractive element 16GB of ram when you dealing with Hyper-V or vmware it could come handy. Personally i much prefer dual grafics (remembe my 1st one 2xVoodoo2 24MB from Diamond) soon we going to hit 4gb on a single card.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are advantaged on both side. Who goes for what is a personal issue (preference)... LOL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Merged into a new thread/topic, I encouraged the discussion I apologize... that was my first move of a bunch of posts I see how it helps organize the forum. Back on topic I will be using the IC diamond on my GPUs and CPU on my incoming M18x it will be the second one I repaste with it so I get a little practice before hand. I believe I am going to try a thicker layer of IC Diamond over the various places Dell has use pads on the video cards to see if all temps can be dropped on the GPUs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By gaffycool
      Hi
      I need urgent help to setup my alienware m18x corrently. Firstly apologies for any typos as I haven't slept in 2 days due to trying to sort this graphics card out.
       
      I have an alienware m18x r1. I recently upgraded to an gtx 880m.. and this is where my life became living hell. I cant seem to install any drivers for it, as Nvidia keeps showing me the 'graphics card cant find compatible hardware'. I then did a lot of research and have found I have to flash the bios. I have been searching for hours on end trying to find tutorials on how to flash the bios, also an unlocked bios for the m18x r1, currently im on the A05 bios.
       
      I do not know why I cant seem to install any driver, even when I try to mod the ini files it doesn't install the driver.
       
      I am at the point now that I will donate whatever you need in terms of money I have paypal, just to get this all working, can anyone help me.
       
       
    • By MC-Sammer
      Over the last month or so, I've been planning on overhauling my (slightly dated) P157SM to give it better cooling, and possibly higher performance.
       
      There were a number of sources I used for inspiration, and I'll attempt to document all of them later on, but first, pictures!

       
      This is the first modification I made. I increased the opening of the CPU fan to allow more air to go into the fan. As I recall, it helped with idle temperatures but I don't remember by how much.
      This picture shows how much I increased the opening by, I didn't do just that bit and stop
       

      Next up, I increased the width of the intakes directly over the GPU and CPU to reduce ambient heat buildup in those areas.
       

       
      I ultimately decided that increasing the width was not the best route to go (and it was quite ugly) so I decided to simply remove the vents
       
      I used some diamond mesh to cover those areas, but I don't have any pictures of that at the moment.
       

       

       
      Next I used some HVAC tape to direct the air flow from the CPU fan into the heatsink and not out the tiny gaps in the area.
       

      Then I swapped out the heatsinks (originally I ordered this from XoticPC and went with their copper cooling upgrade (I was young(er)) for some bigger ones.
       

       

       
      Everything is all nice and snug
       

       
      And finally with the lid back on.
       
      With the changes made between cutting the vents, and the last picture, I was able to drop load CPU temps ~5C which I thought was pretty nice.
       
      My goal is to also get rid of the vent over the fan, but I haven't found time to do it. I'm also planning on lapping the GPU heatsink, which will, again, take time.
       
      I'll post more updates as I make them (and post the benchmarks I've already done).
       
      Update:
      GPU Work:
      So I have a 780M at the moment (I'm planning on going to a 980M, though I may just wait for the Pascal GPU's to come out) and I decided to lap the heatsink, since I'm planning on overclocking it.
       
      Fresh of the block


      400 Grit (10 minutes)

      600 Grit (10 minutes)

      800 Grit (10 minutes)

      1000 grit (7 Minutes)

      1200 Grit (7 Minutes)

      1500 grit (about 25 minutes for this stage)
       
      And I thought it looked pretty smooth. One of my references mentioned cutting off the little tabs on the block, since they're mostly there for adding additional pressure (since the plate is usually warped)  and I wanted to just lap the area directly over the GPU die (plus I don't really have a good place for grinding copper with my rotary tool).
       

       
      For the paste I used http://www.coolermaster.com/cooling/thermal-compound/mastergel-maker/ which I went with based on the favorable review posted at http://www.play3r.net/reviews/cooling/cooler-master-master-gel-maker-nano-thermal-paste-performance/ and the pads are Fujipoly high end (didn't think I'd need to go ultra).
       

       
      I also added some little sinks on to the heatpipes, though they might be suspect (more on that in the results below).
       

       
      And I sealed up a gap in the fan to direct more airflow through the larger fins.
       

       
      I also used from more HVAC tape to try to prevent ambient air from being drawn in to the fans, but this too might be suspect (it might be needed to draw it away, since where else is the heat from all those fins supposed to go?)
       
      And the results are... interesting...
      pre upgrade
      post upgrade
       
      So the initial benchmark had a 5C drop in temperature, but the following results aren't as promising.
      In fact, the stress test results appears to be higher (I'm speculating that it'd be over 86C by 400 seconds).
       
      I'm thinking that either the added heatsinks on the heatpipes are dispersing the heat before it can get to the fins, my lapping job wasn't so great, or I added too much TIM. I may try the washer trick from the p150 cooling threat mentioned below, but I'm spent on energy for this weekend.
       
      June 3rd update
      I finally got back around to working on my clevo some more and after a third re-pasting my temps are down (taking into account that today is hotter than when I first tested)
       
      I suspect that my older paste jobs were either too thick, or I bent the heatpipe and kinda threw the plate out of alignment.
       
      Inspiration:
      Modding my clevo in general:
      http://null-bin.blogspot.com/2015/04/extensive-clevo-p150sm-cooling-and.html
      Sealing up the gaps in the fins:

      Additional cooling ideas:

       
       
       
       
    • By Swick1981
      Hey Everyone,
       
      First off, YOU TAKE FULL RESPONSIBILITY FOR FLASHING THIS!  YOU WILL NOT HOLD ME RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY PROBLEMS YOU MAY RUN IN TO BY FLASHING MY MOD!
      YOU WILL NOT HOLD TECHINFERNO RESPONSIBLE, EITHER!  THIS IS YOUR CHOICE!
       
      Now on to the good stuff...
       
      I've officially cracked it - either by luck or persistence (I'm thinking LUCK, lol) - 
      A11 UNLOCKED BIOS FOR m18Xr2 (UNLOCKED BY SVL7 - FULL CREDIT GOES TO HIM FOR UNLOCKING!)
      Here is what I've added/updated/modded/changed/etc...
      ADDED LEGACY SUPPORT FOR THE m18XR2 -
      You can now run Windows 7 with 900 series nVidia GPU's!  
      Changed the Default GPU from PEG to IGFX - No need to tear down laptop anymore.  8-Beeps are a thing of the PAST!
      Updated the Intel RST Legacy to v12.9.0.2006 (Supports TRIM in RAID0 - CONFIRMED)
      Updated Intel RST UEFI to v12.9.0.2006 (Supports TRIM in RAID0 - CONFIRMED)
      Updated the ONBOARD Video Card for the HD3xxx to v2171 - FROM v2132)
      Updated ONBOARD Video Card for the HD4xxx to v2171 - FROM v2132)
      Updated the LAN Firmware & PXE Boot from 2.0.5.9 to v2.0.6.6)
      ADDED NvMe Support for m18xr2
      ADDED M.2 support for m18xr2
      Updated CPU Microcode to v29 for the 2900 CPU's
      Updated CPU Microcode to v1c for the 3900 CPU's
      Updated CPU Microcode for other supported CPU's if available! Sorry, I don't remember what version, but if it could be updated, it was!)
      Updated GOP Driver for Intel Sandy Bridge
      Updated GOP Driver for Intel Ivy Bridge 
      Updated GOP Policy for the m18xR2
      Raidriar added the "Package C-States Lock" to my bios mod - THANK YOU RAIDRIAR!
       
      YOU TAKE FULL RESPONSIBILITY FOR FLASHING THIS, AS FLASHING CUSTOM BIOS's HAS SOME RISK!!
      I AM IN NO WAY RESPONSIBLE FOR ANYTHING THAT HAPPENS TO YOUR PC BY FLASHING THIS MOD!!
       
      DOWNLOAD INFO:
      My BIOS MOD should be available in the download section of TechInferno!  They have KINDLY offered to host the file, thankfully!  
      You MUST meet the minimum requirements of T|I in order to download files from their download section!  
      PLEASE NOTE:  Do not distribute this file.  Please tell others that want the file to download it from TechInferno, as the file is GUARANTEED to be clean if you get it from here.  If you download it from anywhere else, there is a chance that the code will be changed, and may BRICK your laptop.  Therefore, PLEASE make sure you download from here and ONLY here!   
       
      I'd like to THANK the following people for testing my bios mods to make sure they are safe for the rest of you:
      Mr. Fox, Raidriar, Rengsey R.H. Jr!  Thanks for testing, I'm grateful!
      RAIDRIAR, from nbr, needs an EXTRA shoutout for testing.  He was UTTERLY amazing!  He took risks no sane OR INSANE person would!  I owe him for testing this!  He deserves a LOT of credit for that!
       
       
      Also, I do have an UPDATE to Intel Management Firmware v8.1.64 (I think), but that is a SEPARATE package.  If you are interested, you can do that upgrade, too.  HOWEVER, PLEASE NOTE, if you plan on doing update you MUST do BIOS update FIRST - AGAIN, BIOS UPDATE MUST BE DONE FIRST!  AFTER bios update is done, then you can do IME update.  
      If you update the IME then BIOS, YOU WILL BRICK YOUR SYSTEM!  YOU MUST DO BIOS FIRST, THEN THE Intel ME Update!
       
      If you like this mod that I've done, please donate a couple KEGS of beer to me, as I put a TON of work into this.  I put more hours into this than I should have...  LoL
       
      I can also confirm that this has been tested by MANY people.  Mr. Fox, Raidriar, and a few others, and they had NO issues.  EXCEPT that they were finally able to install Windows 7 while in legacy mode (set from within bios),  and the GPU works completely.  The only ting I am still working on is the throttling issue on ALL GPU's (Some worse than others).  IF you use Mr. Fox's modded drivers, 355.20 I believe, the throttling issue is minimal with the 780m GPUs.  Anything above those drivers seems to throttle all GPU's at a more extreme rate.  I AM working on this throttling issue, but I am not sure it's fixable.  But I will TRY!  
       
      Again, I hope you ALL like this, and that it helps you out.  
      Lastly, IF you flash my MOD and you decide to purchase another 900 series GPU, please make sure you use woodstackz, as he sells them at the best rates.  Please let him know you are purchasing the GPU because of this mod, as it will help me out a little!
       
      I hope you like this!
       
      Swick
       
      Link To Donate:   
       
      EDIT:  I forgot to put fparts.txt in the rar file with all the other files.  sorry about that.  I'm including it here on this post!
      SORRY!
       
      PS.  I AM working on porting ALL these mods to the m17xR4, but dont know if I can get LEGACY SUPPORT ported!  I AM TRYING,  but if I can't, I'll be able to port EVERYTHING else...
       
      File download link:

       
       
       
       
    • By Doki
      Hello everone,
       
      i just want to share you some Hardware mod ideas for the p170hm.
      the goal was to improve the airflow for the fans, while maintaining a decent look of the notebook case.
       
      overall improvements:
      GPU (GTX680M OC) about 7°C drop at 100% load
      CPU (i7 2820QM) about 6° drop at 100% load
       
      not sure if the two small fans helping that much. you guys think its better if they would suck in the cold air instead of blowing hot air out?
       
      the fans are 30x30x7mm. the power is taken from the sata connector.
       
      this took me about 3 hours to make.
       
       









    • By Swick1981
      Hey Everyone,
      Well, I was FINALLY able to MOD a fully UNLOCKED A05 Bios for the m18x R1. 
      I created several BIOS's that have the following Intel Raid OpRom v10.5, 11.2, 11.6, 12.9, 13.5.  I'm told that 12.9.0 is the BEST version to use with our m18xR1.  Also, these ROMS are modded to give TRIM on a RAID0 system!  I've tested it and can confirm it does work!
      I also have an intel ME Firmware upgrade that you can do, as well, but I only sugest people that know what they are doing use it.  Only because, for some reason, if you flash the ME firmware, then the Bios, there is a problem and you can brick your ME Firmware.  (You'd need a new motherboard).  It locks your firmware. 
      Anyway, if you flash the bios that you want, and not even deal with upgrading the ME, then you're fine.  But, if you do the ME firmware upgrade like I did, if you flash and bios's, you will need to downgrade the FW, before any BIOS flashing...  (I THINK).
      In any case, you may just want to stick with the BIOS upgrade, as this will give you TRIM in RAID0 support (confirmed with trimtool).
      If interested, please let me know!
      Thanks,
      Swick