Jump to content
Samseed

Frankensteins lappy

Recommended Posts

While searching for the solution to my various problems I began wondering if there were any other motherboards that will fit into my gt70 case (or any another msi case for that matter)

What are the physical differences between the various models of msi motherboards and how many are swappable/compatible?

Is an msi Frankenstein possible?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it's not just motherboard. HDD boards are different, GT70 has DisplayPort where eSATA used to be, etc.

We discussed this in the past, there are some other components you will need to get to make this "frankenstein". Pictures included in the post.
Perhaps some case modifications will be necessary too. But if you are skilled enough, you could make it work.

If you do, don't forget to let us know. And perhaps add some pictures too. (Thunderbolt in the background and you screaming "It's alive !!! " )

;)

 

read more here:

 

and here:

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can see it now..the staticky hair, a wild look of satisfaction in my eyes..

 

But where to start that is the problem. Just finding images of anything after ms-1763 for comparison is a mind numbing task.

The GT72 board, although vastly different component wise, does maintain the same general shape. A few new "access ports" in the chassis and it might actually be functional but short of actually getting my hands on one its a little tough to plan a project like that and was hoping someone might have a list of similar or compatible boards. If only MSI had devoted an advertising budget to their mobile boards as well. :logik:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Bugii said:

it's not just motherboard. HDD boards are different, GT70 has DisplayPort where eSATA used to be, etc.

We discussed this in the past, there are some other components you will need to get to make this "frankenstein". Pictures included in the post.
Perhaps some case modifications will be necessary too. But if you are skilled enough, you could make it work.

If you do, don't forget to let us know. And perhaps add some pictures too. (Thunderbolt in the background and you screaming "It's alive !!! " )

;)

 

read more here:

 

and here:

Yes,MS-1762 and MS-1763 are possible in MS-1761,but you need also another Touchpanel and new HHD Adapter.

The Touchpanelconnestor and HDD Connector from MS-1762 are different ,all other are the same.

The Connector from MS-1762 and MS-1763 are also different.

 

Hello

 

You

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Samseed said:

I can see it now..the staticky hair, a wild look of satisfaction in my eyes..

 

But where to start that is the problem. Just finding images of anything after ms-1763 for comparison is a mind numbing task.

The GT72 board, although vastly different component wise, does maintain the same general shape. A few new "access ports" in the chassis and it might actually be functional but short of actually getting my hands on one its a little tough to plan a project like that and was hoping someone might have a list of similar or compatible boards. If only MSI had devoted an advertising budget to their mobile boards as well. :logik:

 

Board can be obtained here. http://www.laptopinventory.com/ModelDetail.php/MSI/GT Series/GT72 2QE/Motherboards ~ System/36168

note, this was just a quick google search, I have no experience with that shop.

 

Yes, planning without having the board in hands is challenge.

You could try to find and buy damaged board for cheap - just to have something to try if it fits and then get the working one.

 

Question is, the board costs 450bucks. You can find completely working (although used/refurbished) GT72 on ebay for about 1000usd.

IMHO it would be much less of a risk to simply sell GT70 and buy used GT72 (assuming you have 450 for the board already) and you're done.

 

Or if your goal is not to have GT72 but to do this "frankenstein project" instead, you can buy used GT72 and simply sell the parts you don't use.

Please note, GT72 has "xxxxHQ" cpu. It's soldered to mobo, unlike the one you have in GT70 now.

 

 

Edited by Bugii

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is why I get so confused when thinking about this project. Both of these are listed as MS-17811 V 1.0  and they look nothing like the one you posted(bottom)

MSI-GT72-Disassembly-24-600x400.jpg

 

ms-17811-msi-motherboard-intel-sr1px-i7-

motherboard.JPG

This is my conundrum. Do I spend $400+ on the off chance the chassis can be modified or spend 1000+ for a used rig that I can play mad scientist with. Of course if I have a working 72 why bother right? 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The GT72 Board is not compatible for GT70,i have a damaged Board here.

Don`t think about this,this is impossible.

The Latest Version of GT70 is MS-1763.

And for this You need also both HDD Adapter,if You find this You must pay more than 400€ with CPU.

Then You can sell Your old MS-1761 and buy a used MS-1763,ist cheaper.

And the GT72 with i7-6700HQ and GTX 980M is  slower than my GT70 with i7-4900MQ and GTX 980M.

GT70:

http://www.3dmark.com/3dm11/11553413

GT72:

http://www.3dmark.com/3dm11/11586297

The GT70 is with the right Componenets a good Base and absolut Up to Date.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Bloetschkopf said:

Don`t think about this,this is impossible.

 

Nothing is impossible my friend :)

I saw a post here on T|I  of a guy who soldered desktop GTX980 core to a mobile PCB and got it working. Respect.

 

1 hour ago, Bloetschkopf said:

The GT72 Board is not compatible for GT70,i have a damaged Board here.

Don`t think about this,this is impossible.

The Latest Version of GT70 is MS-1763.

And for this You need also both HDD Adapter,if You find this You must pay more than 400€ with CPU.

Then You can sell Your old MS-1761 and buy a used MS-1763,ist cheaper.

And the GT72 with i7-6700HQ and GTX 980M is  slower than my GT70 with i7-4900MQ and GTX 980M.

GT70:

http://www.3dmark.com/3dm11/11553413

GT72:

http://www.3dmark.com/3dm11/11586297

The GT70 is with the right Componenets a good Base and absolut Up to Date.

 

 

Interesting results.

So yeah, it looks like the GT70 (1763) is better option.

Since GT72 does not support Pascal cards (yet) There's really no point of upgrading GT70 to GT72. Both of them can utilize GTX980M

(off topic. I found some ASUS GTX 1060 mxm cards. I'm buying one and I'll see if it will work in my GT70. I'll post the results once I have it)

 

1 hour ago, Samseed said:

and they look nothing like the one you posted(bottom)

Could be just a "wrong picture" - not the actual photo of the board. Better ask the seller first.

 

1 hour ago, Samseed said:

of course if I have a working 72 why bother right? 

 

yes, this is exactly the point. If you ONLY want an upgrade, just get GT70 motherboard - the one for 1763 version and stick 980M in it.

But some people don't care about getting better machine. They are doing this just to see if it is possible. - That's why bother ;) to be the first one to do it.

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bet the majority of those images are mislabeled somehow and the variety is simply stupendous. I dont know why they insist on changing there boards so drastically, every single iteration. 

Being limited by your hardware is no fun when you want a custom machine even if you are willing to remove the side panels :D.

In the end you can only ever take it so far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, Bugii said:

 

Nothing is impossible my friend :)

I saw a post here on T|I  of a guy who soldered desktop GTX980 core to a mobile PCB and got it working. Respect.

 

Interesting results.

So yeah, it looks like the GT70 (1763) is better option.

Since GT72 does not support Pascal cards (yet) There's really no point of upgrading GT70 to GT72. Both of them can utilize GTX980M

(off topic. I found some ASUS GTX 1060 mxm cards. I'm buying one and I'll see if it will work in my GT70. I'll post the results once I have it)

 

Could be just a "wrong picture" - not the actual photo of the board. Better ask the seller first.

 

 

yes, this is exactly the point. If you ONLY want an upgrade, just get GT70 motherboard - the one for 1763 version and stick 980M in it.

But some people don't care about getting better machine. They are doing this just to see if it is possible. - That's why bother ;) to be the first one to do it.

 

     

Change a GPU Chip is easy with the right Tools,a little Risk yes.

But change a Board with complete different Layout is impossible,have a look at the Picture.

 

Where You bought the Asus GTX 1060?

Is it normal MXM 3.0 ?

 

     

 

21 hours ago, Bugii said:

 

 

IMG_1536.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Bloetschkopf said:

Change a GPU Chip is easy with the right Tools,a little Risk yes.

But change a Board with complete different Layout is impossible,have a look at the Picture.

 

Where You bought the Asus GTX 1060?

Is it normal MXM 3.0 ?

 

   

 

I see.
that would need a really heavy chassis modding. New board is longer so I guess you'd need to sacrifice one HDD and optical drive in order to cut a hole into chassis to stick this in. Custom made heatsink is also necessary.

 

GTX1060 MXM3.0b here:

 

https://world.taobao.com/item/538144341448.htm?spm=a312a.7700714.0.0.wm7MeZ#detail

 

 

Yes, standard MXM 3.0b - GTX 980M next to it for comparison.

I wanted 1070 but those cards are bigger, won't fit into my GT70 chassis, and they have additional power connector. This one looks compatible.

Edited by Bugii

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
46 minutes ago, Bugii said:

 

I see.
that would need a really heavy chassis modding. New board is longer so I guess you'd need to sacrifice one HDD and optical drive in order to cut a hole into chassis to stick this in. Custom made heatsink is also necessary.

 

GTX1060 MXM3.0b here:

 


https://world.taobao.com/item/538144341448.htm?spm=a312a.7700714.0.0.wm7MeZ#detail

 

 

Yes, standard MXM 3.0b - GTX 980M next to it for comparison.

I wanted 1070 but those cards are bigger, won't fit into my GT70 chassis, and they have additional power connector. This one looks compatible.

I know this Card,but this is a MSI Card.

maybe I'll buy them also , i will ask my Sister in Law there.

If the Card have G-Sync it will not work in GT70,i think it have G-Sync.

GTX980M G-Sync and Qudro M3000M also not working right in  GT70.

Driver Installing is no Problem,but 3Dmark11 runs ony with 8 Frames.

And in the mobil Nvidia Control Panel You can`t switch off G-Sync.

There is no Option for this.

Maybe it is possible with another Nvidia Control Panel with complete Menu.

How You bought it?

Maybe Your Way  is easier for me.

Edited by Bloetschkopf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

After an evening of googling, would it be safe to assume that the the best we can hope for is an i7-3740qm, gtx98m, ms-17631 for the gt70 chassis? A bit disappointing considering the possibilities with the new architecture but should still be quite the performer.

https://world.taobao.com/item/538144341448.htm?spm=a312a.7700714.0.0.wm7MeZ#detail

This is looks promising but would you happen to have the codename for that card, I cant read it off the chip?

 

There is a nice thread going about the 1000 series  http://forum.notebookreview.com/threads/upgrade-mxm-or-wait-for-new-1000-series-cards.792965/page-11

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/23/2016 at 10:37 PM, Bloetschkopf said:

I know this Card,but this is a MSI Card.

maybe I'll buy them also , i will ask my Sister in Law there.

If the Card have G-Sync it will not work in GT70,i think it have G-Sync.

GTX980M G-Sync and Qudro M3000M also not working right in  GT70.

Driver Installing is no Problem,but 3Dmark11 runs ony with 8 Frames.

And in the mobil Nvidia Control Panel You can`t switch off G-Sync.

There is no Option for this.

Maybe it is possible with another Nvidia Control Panel with complete Menu.

How You bought it?

Maybe Your Way  is easier for me.

 

Hmm they say asus in description. It doe snot have G-sync enabled. Neither does SLI bridge. And you need eDP not LVDS. That's what it says in description if I'm not mistaken.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 9/24/2016 at 2:35 AM, Samseed said:

 

 

After an evening of googling, would it be safe to assume that the the best we can hope for is an i7-3740qm, gtx98m, ms-17631 for the gt70 chassis? A bit disappointing considering the possibilities with the new architecture but should still be quite the performer.


https://world.taobao.com/item/538144341448.htm?spm=a312a.7700714.0.0.wm7MeZ#detail

This is looks promising but would you happen to have the codename for that card, I cant read it off the chip?

 

There is a nice thread going about the 1000 series  http://forum.notebookreview.com/threads/upgrade-mxm-or-wait-for-new-1000-series-cards.792965/page-11

 

i7-4xxxQM will also work.
Can't read the chip code from that picture. But that should be the same for all gtx 1060 chips. And yes, it looks like it's MSI PCB.

This has not been tested yet however. So far, 980M is the best confirmed GPU you can get.

  • Thumbs Up 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Soapy
      I reversed the input polarity on my m15x jack after a botched psu repair. Computer worked fine, but overall power control is messed up. System only boot on both battery and psu, no battery charge, and a very low battery drain (arround 6wh).
       
      I aways had battery issues whith my 8 years old m15x after my original battery died. Bought a new one two years ago, didn't work. Checked on upower, basically no info on manufacturer, power or history. So i refunded and used the system hooked on the psu as usual. In August i bought a new one, worked flawlessly for a day. The next day the battery died from nowere. Checked upower, bus was ok, battery was charging extremely slowly (6wh), history showed subpar disharge before shutting down. I got mad at this point, decided that psu was to blame. Opened it, checked everything, noticed some wear on the male jack. Resoldered it, connected on computer. Nothing happened, so i checked the voltage. That's when i realised that i screwed up big time. I swaped the positive and negative wires. Decided that one mistake was enough, so i sent my m15x to a trusted repair shop (latter found that they just hooked the battery and gave me back as soon as it booted, they didnt even open it). Got my pc a week later, but the battery didn't charge . Worse, it was slowly discharging (same 6wh as before), and it needed both the psu and the battery to turn on. At 65%, it worked as usual for my college semester, but the battery is dead, and so is my computer. I bellieve i burned some voltage controller or something. I'm pretty competent at soldering thing's (evem smd components) when i know what to do, and i can understand simple circuit's, but when i got my hands on the m15x datasheet i got overblown. I cant make heads or tails about it. I aways lurked this forum and i bellieve your guys are the best when it comes to finding creative solutions to technical problems concerning microelectronics. I followed a guide in this forum as a teenager to upgrade this same computer to a gtx680m, overclocked stuff, got custom bios, and had a lot of fun learning. The m15x is a deprecated platform, but it's a part of my history that i dont want to let go.
      So please guys, help me.
       
    • By BAKED
      Hey y'all! I'm planning on releasing BIOS mods for the newer MSI laptops.
      So I'm looking for some testers to evaluate my mods and give input.
      If you're interested just PM me and we'll take it from there 
    • By BAKED
      There are several threads on requesting BIOS modifications here on T | I but I thought another one wouldn't hurt.
       
            Your request should look like:
      Brand Model Type of modification(For example: Unlocked, added support, Logo, microcode, ME firmware etc  
      I'll respond as soon as I have time as I'm also currently working on other projects(Requests by PM is also ok)
      If anyone else have the knowledge and time feel free to respond to requests 
       
    • By Edrc
      Hello,
       
      I am new on this forum, so I am sorry if posting at the wrong place. It's been 2 weeks that I am searching how to make my GTX 980M 8GB working Inside my Alienware 17 R1 (June 2014, i7 4710MQ, 60 Herts Display, OPTIMUS and the GTX 880M Inside died.)
      After "quickly" looking some forums, I saw that a 980M would easily fit Inside … but maybe I was wrong.
       
      Hardware wasn't a problem. I've also could install drivers by modding the nvdmi or nvcvi. inf files. The card was recognied BUT :
      the clock speed is locked a 135 or 405 Mherts and fan is not runing when booted up.
      I tried to flash vBios with nvflash and some ROM I found on vBios collection … but no way to get this working properly.
       
      So, i'm coming here. I've seen many people talking about Prema or svl7 or other big boss in the place … but ? how ? where ? when ?
       
      Inside the peripherial manager I have this in remote acces path : PCI\VEN_10DE&DEV_1617&SUBSYS_05AA1028&REV_A1\4&D590A51&0&0008
      So I assume my GTX 980M card ID is 1617 and vendor and PC Model are 05AA 1028.
      But near the "Standard Microsoft Video Card" there is a yellow exclamation point and Inside details it says "this peripherial doesn't work properly" when no Nvidia drivers installed.
      I could find some vBios with 1617 (Asus) but black screen at boot up. Since laptop model where not the same .. probably.
      And I wasn't able to find 1617 with the existing 05AA 1028 … as the GTX 980M was not an option for my model. (AW 17 R1 2014 ,60Herts)
      I tried 353.60, 382.33 and 419.35 drivers. The latest one seems easier to install but longer.
       
      BIOS is A16 from Dell. And I am using Windows 10. Got a Dell 330W brick. 
       
      I saw a guy with the exact model as me, he gets a modded vBios especially for his configuration, then everything worked easily … but can't find the topic again
       
      I guess depending on the card info and the laptop model … a dedicated vBios is required … 
       
      So, If anyone here got some informations or any kind of help for me, it would be very nice.
       
      Thanks for reading and help.  
       
      PS: there are a lot of files, pictures and links that I can't see on this forum .. even after registration …. 
       
    • By aBug
      Hello Everyone!
       
      I have problem with VBIOS/EEPROM(?) after installing of a GTX1060 N17E-G1-A1 GPU NVIDIA Graphics Chipset (old one has temp. damages). 
       
      I  modified new 416  and old 391 nvmii.inf file and try to install drivers, but every combination gave me no success. There is only yellow triangle in  Windows Device Manager :|
      Is there a way to bring my card to life?
       
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.